Subscribe To Blog

Your email:

whitepapers for download

read this week's news

Subscribe To Our Mailing List 2 (resized)

Pearse Trust Blog

Current Articles | RSS Feed RSS Feed

The Variations & Similarities Of Foundations & Trusts

 

The Variations & Similarities Of Foundations & Trusts  Trusts and Foundations are used for very similar purposes and there are various aspects of these structures which are alike. However, there are crucial differences between the two and each is very unique in its own right. 

In brief, a Trust may be defined as a legal arrangement whereby a person transfers ownership and control of assets to a Trustee to hold and manage on behalf of Beneficiaries or for a specific purpose.  A Foundation may be described as a self-governing legal entity which is managed by a Foundation Council which is set up by a Founder following the registration of the Foundation for the benefit of Beneficiaries or for a specified purpose. 

Similarities

Purposes

Both are regularly used for the efficient holding of wealth, asset protection and succession planning purposes.

Liability Of The Trustee / Council

In a Foundation, it is the Council who has powers to manage the assets. Comparably, in a Trust, the Trustees manage the assets in accordance with the terms of the Trust.

Confidentiality

Trusts are private arrangements and the Beneficiaries are only known internally. Likewise anonymity is provided by a Foundation. Although the statutes of a Foundation are registered, the regulations detailing the Beneficiaries are only known internally.

Differences

Legal Entity

A Foundation is a separate legal entity which may hold assets, whereas a Trust is not a separate legal entity and the Trustees must therefore hold the assets vested in same. 

Reservations Of Rights & Powers

In a Trust, it is unlikely that the Settlor will reserve rights and powers. However, in a Foundation, it is more usual for the Founder to reserve certain rights and powers. 

Protector

In particular jurisdictions a Protector is required to be appointed to a Foundation. However, trust law does not require that a Protector must be appointed. 

Governing Law

The governing law of a Foundation is the state of registration, whereas the governing law of a Trust is chosen by the Settlor in the Trust instrument.

Testamentary Trust / Foundations

A Foundation may be created to take effect after the Founder’s death and so the formalities of a will are not required. However, a Trust which intends to take effect after the Settlor’s death must conform to the formalities of a will.

Both a Trust and a Foundation can present several opportunities, benefits and advantages for individuals and firms. Although they are similar and can be used for similar purposes, the differences between the two are important and should be considered when planning a structure to manage assets.

Related Blog Posts

Download Whitepaper

new zealand trusts

 

Download our whitepaper on New Zealand Trusts.

Comments

One further issue is the question of "seat" or effective residence for both legal and fiscal purposes. What some advisors fail to acknowledge is the differential in Europe between the siège réel and the siège social. The French in particlar have been known to redomcile a foundation or a corporate entity on the basis that its seat fo everyday managment and administration is in France for both tax and legal purposes. You cna therefroe find yourself in front fo a French court having the French codes being applied to what is formally a foreign entity on that basis. Hence my propossl, which was accepted, that the Jersey Foundation law be amended to enable a Jersey Foundation to fix its seat of business in Jersey. 
As you are aware, the accounting attempts to reduce or redefine a "trusts" residence by reference to corporate notions of management and control have led to some dificulties as a trust is not a legal entity. The question remains unresolved whether as a property law matter it is effectively attached to the jurisdiction of situs of the assets in trust, or, a method adopted in the UK, by reference to a statutory definition for certain, but not all taxes.
Posted @ Monday, December 12, 2011 5:23 AM by Peter Harris
it would be interesting to compare the treatment of trusts and Foundations in the UK and the US when tax matters are considered. 
 
in the past the tax authorities in these countries tended to treat a Foundation as if it was a body corporate,a corporation. 
 
in 2099 the Irs issued a letter of clarification stating that in certain cirmumstances they would be willing to treat a Foundation as a Trust for tax purposes. 
 
it would be good to hear from members of the group their feedback on this important issue. 
 
alon kaplan
Posted @ Saturday, December 17, 2011 2:27 PM by alon kaplan
Post Comment
Name
 *
Email
 *
Website (optional)
Comment
 *

Allowed tags: <a> link, <b> bold, <i> italics